The failures of Environmental, Social, and Governance (ESG) regulations have highlighted the need for stronger measures to address climate change. A writer who co-edited a book on the subject notes that the effectiveness of ESG has diminished, as the movement’s voluntary standards have proven ineffective in driving meaningful change.
The ESG movement began as a well-meaning effort by the United Nations and large institutional investors to leverage business power in solving collective action problems, including climate and biodiversity crises. However, the development of voluntary standards proved impractical, leading to a proliferation of competing standards that companies could pick and choose from.
Limitations of ESG
The voluntary ESG movement gave the impression that institutional investors and business firms cared about their environmental and social impacts as well as their bottom-line profits, but this turned out to be an illusion. Proponents of ESG defined standards in terms of traditional measures of financial materiality, considering ESG factors relevant to corporate decision-making only insofar as they impacted the financial bottom line.
The standards suffered from vagueness and imprecision, and voluntary ESG standards lacked regulation. This led to a situation where companies could game the system by choosing which values to emphasize for public relations purposes and ignoring others. A recent report estimates that climate change may cause 14.5 million deaths and $12.5 trillion in economic losses worldwide by 2050.
A writer who has developed ideas on the subject notes that one obvious solution is to turn away politicians who deny climate science. However, this approach requires seeing through political messaging funded by wealthy business interests, especially in the fossil fuel and artificial intelligence industries, which favor inertia and inaction.
Read Also: US Measles Outbreak Sparks Vaccine Policy Debate
In addition to engaging in politics, everyday people and businesses can take action. The European Union has been charting a path forward with regulations such as the Corporate Sustainability Reporting Directive and the Corporate Sustainability Due Diligence Directive, which are mandatory and extraterritorial. These regulations adopt a “double materiality” approach, recognizing that sustainability impacts cannot be reduced to financial terms.
Mandatory Disclosure Standards
These regulations require firms to show they are acting as good citizens as well as profitable ones. A Wharton School colleague and the writer praise these EU regulations but lament that they do not connect reporting and due diligence directives on sustainability with corporate fiduciary duties. The writer argues that mandatory disclosure standards are a potential means toward an eventual end of reforming fiduciary duties to move away from the profit maximization paradigm and toward including other important values, including climate and biodiversity preservation.
The writer discusses the drift in Delaware corporate law toward profit maximization as a governing paradigm and recognizes that the business judgment rule and “permissive” fiduciary standards still provide corporate managers and officers some degree of discretion.
The writer identifies a big problem in the separation of ownership and control incorporations between shareholders and managers, which has morphed into a new split between the fiduciary duties of investors, which sometimes mandate profit maximization, and those of top managers, which tend to remain more flexible in allowing consideration of other values. This bi-level fiduciary structure means that firms are forced to adopt the profit maximization paradigm in practice more often than theoretical frameworks suggest.
The solution, according to the writer, is to reform fiduciary duties, which lie at the heart of corporate law. The profit maximization paradigm was imported into corporate law relatively recently, and corporate law can be reformed to respect values other than those dictated by a narrow view of economics. The writer notes that this change is only “radical” in the sense of returning to the roots of basic understandings of fiduciary duty.
Read Also: California cracks down on unsafe high-speed e-bikes
As for other solutions, the writer’s work focuses on the role that individual consumers can play in driving change. Consumers can use their everyday power to act consistently with their values in making purchases, such as buying electric cars, and can concentrate this pressure by acting in concert. The writer is currently working on a chapter about climate cooperatives, which can prove useful in sectors such as local renewable energy production and climate finance.
The EU’s Corporate Sustainability Reporting Directive, for example, requires companies to disclose information about their sustainability impacts, including their environmental and social effects.
Eric W. Orts, the Guardsmark Professor of Legal Studies and Business Ethics and Professor of Management at the Wharton School of the University of Pennsylvania, emphasizes the need for reforming corporate fiduciary duties. He notes that corporate law can be reformed to respect values other than those dictated by a narrow view of economics, and that this change is only “radical” in the sense of returning to the roots of basic understandings of fiduciary duty.
Climate Cooperatives and Alternative Business Structures
Orts argues that these regulations are a step in the right direction, but that more needs to be done to connect reporting and due diligence directives with corporate fiduciary duties.
