Court bans publication of identities in eSafety Telegram case

by Marigold Thorne • 4 hours ago
Court bans publication of identities in eSafety Telegram case
Federal Court of Australia.

The Federal Court of Australia has granted pseudonymity and non-publication orders in a proceeding brought by the eSafety Commissioner against Telegram FZ-LLC and Telegram Messenger Inc. The court issued orders to protect the safety of certain individuals and to prevent prejudice to the proper administration of justice.

Legal Basis of the Proceedings

The case concerns the Online Safety (Relevant Electronic Services – Class 1A and Class 1B Material) Industry Standard 2024, which was created under section 145(1) of the Online Safety Act 2021. The eSafety Commissioner is seeking declarations and pecuniary penalties, arguing that Telegram violated section 146(1) of the Act.

The commissioner contends that the platform facilitated access to or the distribution of class 1A material. Under the standard, this includes “pro-terror material” or “extreme crime and violence material.” In her statement of claim, the commissioner asserted that end-users in Australia identified 12 examples of this material on the service, with three classified as “known pro-terror material.”

Read Also: Women underrepresented in senior law roles

Users reported each instance to Telegram, which failed to remove 10 of the 12 instances within seven days. The commissioner argued that the relevant Telegram entity failed to maintain systems and processes for responding to breaches of terms of use relating to class 1A material, set up appropriate systems, processes, and technologies to detect, remove, disrupt, and deter known pro-terror material, and give any notification in response to the complaints.

Furthermore, the commissioner’s application for pseudonym orders was based on the need to protect witness safety and prevent prejudice to the administration of justice, particularly in connection with the determination of whether the services abided by the Online Safety Act and the prosecution of civil penalty proceedings in the event of non-compliance. The court issued orders to refer to the employer company as ‘company Y,’ to refer to its CEO as ‘Mr X,’ and to refer to the two proposed witnesses as ‘Person A’ and ‘Person B.’

Protection Measures and Orders

These measures are designed to protect individuals under section 37AG(1)(c) of the Federal Court of Australia Act 1976.

Read Also: Awards honor top legal tech providers

The court imposed a 10-year prohibition over the publication of any information potentially divulging the identities of Person A, Person B, Mr X, or company Y, as well as company Y’s address. The publication, disclosure, or access by most people of the following confidential information is prohibited without a court order: The court similarly restricted access to confidential information, including specific paragraphs from Ms Snell’s affidavit and portions of the CEO’s affidavit, as well as the commissioner’s written submissions from November 5, 2026.

On 21 May 2026, the Federal Court of Australia ordered X Corp, which operated the social media service formerly known as Twitter, to pay $650k to the Commonwealth of Australia as a pecuniary penalty and $100k as a contribution to the eSafety Commissioner’s costs. This decision highlights the eSafety Commissioner’s efforts to enforce compliance with the Online Safety Act and protect individuals from harmful online content.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *